Welcome to Mutz Pizzeria, a delightful haven for pizza lovers located at 212B S Main St, Middleton, MA. This pizza destination is not just about satisfying your cravings—it's about exploring bold flavors and creative combinations that elevate traditional pizza to an unforgettable experience.
Upon entering, you’re greeted by a modern, edgy ambiance featuring a bold black and pink theme. The atmosphere is friendly and inviting, a perfect place to enjoy a meal with friends or even indulge in some solo dining while appreciating the vibrant vibe. The energy is palpable, with Marco, the Pizza Man, engaging warmly with customers, making you feel right at home.
Let’s talk about the stars of the show: the pizzas. Mutz Pizzeria has mastered the art of crafting delicious, innovative pizzas that cater to all tastes. The red pizza menu boasts classic favorites like the Classic Cheese, with its homemade sauce and velvety mozzarella. If you’re feeling adventurous, try Pizzaman's Fav, where pepperoni meets banana peppers drizzled with hot honey—sweet and spicy perfection!
The South Main Combo is another standout, featuring savory sausage, roasted peppers, and caramelized onions that create a symphony of flavors with each bite. Then there’s the intriguingly named I Don’t Like Spam, which combines thinly sliced Spam, fresh pineapple, and jalapenos—a pizza that defies expectations. You can even indulge in their exceptional white pizzas like the Plum Tomato and the unique What’s Da Dill? with its dill sauce and pickled onions, making for a refreshing twist on pizza. This mix of classic and unconventional toppings ensures that every visit presents a new adventure.
Customer reviews echo the sentiment that Mutz Pizzeria is a must-try. Chris Ayers lauds the tangy red sauce and quality toppings that define North Shore pizza. Meanwhile, Carol McGee shares her enthusiasm for the roasted veggie pizza, praising its fresh ingredients and crisp, thin crust—a testament to Mutz's commitment to quality.
Many diners highlight the remarkable dipping sauces, particularly the homemade ranch, which one customer deemed "the best we’ve ever had." The attention to detail in these side offerings enhances the pizza experience even further, making every bite an exploration of flavors.
If you’re searching for a pizza joint that defies the ordinary, Mutz Pizzeria is a culinary treasure you cannot afford to miss. The fresh ingredients, unique flavor profiles, and welcoming atmosphere combine to create an outstanding dining experience. It’s no wonder that customers rave about the place, with reviews urging others to “run, don’t walk” to try their creations. So, what are you waiting for? Dive into the pizza adventure at Mutz Pizzeria—it’s an experience that promises to delight!
Your opinion matters! Help other visitors discover this spot. Your email will stay private. Fields with * are required.
4030 Lawrenceville Hwy Ste 8, Lilburn, GA 30047, United States
Carrer Catalunya, 11, 17867 Camprodon, Girona, Spain
Via Giuseppe Verdi, 77, 38122 Trento TN, Italy
TS 2644, Jalan Bukit Tambun, Bukit Tambun, 14110 Simpang Ampat, Pulau Pinang, Malaysia
Minca, Santa Marta, Magdalena, Colombia
Chris Ayers
14/10/2025
Delicious North Shore pizza with quality toppings and tangy red sauce. Marco the Pizza Man runs the show and is always chatting with customers.
Carol McGee
13/10/2025
First time trying pizza here. It is definitely a take out place with only benches available for your wait. I got the roasted veggie without garlic and honestly it was the most amazing pizza I’ve had in years. I am wow’ed ! Fresh vegetables , thin crust with good amount of sauce and cheese. See my pic ! And the staff are helpful, friendly and patient with me trying to choose from their good size menu of red and white pizzas.
Melanie Espinola
08/09/2025
Run, Don’t Walk—Mutz Pizza is a Must-Try! We finally got to experience Mutz after countless recommendations, and let me tell you—it’s every bit as incredible as people promised! From the moment we took our first bite, we were hooked. We tried the cheese, chicken bacon ranch, and South Main pizzas, and each one was a masterpiece. The thin, crispy crust was absolutely perfect, baked to golden perfection. What really blew us away was the house ranch it’s hands down the best we’ve ever had. It wasn’t just a sauce, it was an experience! Mutz has truly mastered the art of pizza and dipping sauces. This was our first visit, but it definitely won’t be our last. If you’re debating whether to try it—don’t! Trust us, this is the best pizza around.
Jason Ott
30/08/2025
Came all the way from NW Indiana to eat here! It did not disappoint... The pickle pizza was the best I've had, amazing flavors. Toppings on both pizza were evenly placed and didn't skimp on any of them.
Fras Soputan
22/08/2025
I absolutely loved my experience at Mutz Pizzeria! This place is a game-changer when it comes to pizza. What sets them apart is their unique flavor combinations and their creative, unconventional menu. It’s not your average pizza joint, every bite feels like a new adventure. I tried The "Posty," the Loaded Potato, and The Aussie, and wow, they were all incredibly flavorful! Each pizza had its own distinct personality, and I couldn’t pick a favorite if I tried. The ingredients were fresh, the crust was perfect, and the flavors just popped in the best way possible. On top of the amazing food, the vibe of the place is so cool! The black and pink theme gives it a modern, edgy feel that makes dining there even more fun. It’s the kind of spot you’d want to hang out at with friends or even just enjoy solo while soaking in the atmosphere. If you’re looking for pizza that’s anything but ordinary, Mutz Pizzeria is a must-try. I can’t wait to go back and explore more of their menu.. highly recommend!
Travis
14/08/2025
We've ordered her a few times now when playing pool at the Clubhouse next door. Pizza is really good. Nice crust, high quality dough and lots of variety to choose from. Only negative reviews seem to be some weird personal gripe with the owner.
Mary Pelrine
11/08/2025
You always get the same delicious pizza whenever you visit Mutz Pizzeria! The wonderful benefit of visiting Mutz Pizzeria is meeting the remarkable owners Gina and Marco, and their friendly employees who treat you like family. I highly recommend Mutz Pizzeria for your next pizza with a crispy crust and toppings of your choice.
Anthony Kunevich
23/07/2025
My girlfriend and I stopped by here after spending a day in Salem to finally be able to try out Mutz pizzeria as I’ve been following their social media for a few years now. I grabbed the chicken bacon ranch pizza and my girlfriend tried the “white iverson” and we were both blown away with the taste, it was absolutely amazing! The hot honey is such a nice touch to the chicken bacon ranch pizza and it was just a great experience overall, you can tell the ingredients are fresh and prepared daily. Marco was very friendly and showed great hospitality and the rest of the crew were great to speak with and gave us great service! I’m bummed out I don’t live close to here but I for sure will be making future visits in the future if I’m in the area, an instant favorite for sure!